Nose Job Surgery at The Seattle Rhinoplasty Center The Seattle Rhinoplasty Center, board-certified,plastic surgeon

What Is The Difference Between Open Rhinoplasty And Closed Rhinoplasty

What Is The Difference Between Open Rhinoplasty And Closed Rhinoplasty

Are you considering rhinoplasty surgery? If so, it’s important to understand the differences between open and closed rhinoplasty. As a rhinoplasty surgeon, I have extensive experience in both techniques and can provide you with the information you need to make an informed decision about your treatment.

The primary distinction between open and closed rhinoplasty is the way in which the nose is accessed during surgery. In an open procedure, small incisions are made at either side of the nostrils, allowing me to lift the nasal skin away from its underlying structures for more detailed reshaping. In closed rhinoplasty, all of the work is done through hidden incisions made inside the nostrils.

Both methods offer unique advantages and disadvantages that must be considered when making a decision regarding which technique would best suit your individual needs. In this article I will discuss these differences in detail, helping you understand why one method may be preferable to another depending on your desired aesthetic outcome.

Definition Of Open Rhinoplasty

Open rhinoplasty is a surgical procedure used to reshape the nose. It’s also known as external rhinoplasty because it involves making an incision at the base of the columella, which is the strip of tissue connecting the nostrils. This allows for direct visualization and manipulation of the nasal structures during surgery. The surgeon can then carefully reshape and refine the nasal tip and bridge, along with other necessary changes such as removing cartilage or bone. Open rhinoplasty offers greater access to all areas in order to provide more control over the results.

The technique also allows for better visualization of potential problems that may be present before surgery, such as asymmetry or irregularities in the nose structure. This helps ensure that any corrections made are done accurately and precisely. Additionally, open rhinoplasty provides a smoother transition between altered parts of the nose, as well as improved definition of finer details such as nostril shape and size.

Overall, open rhinoplasty enables surgeons to achieve beautiful cosmetic results with precision and accuracy while providing a safe environment for patients undergoing this type of procedure.

Definition Of Closed Rhinoplasty

Closed rhinoplasty, also known as endonasal rhinoplasty, is a surgical procedure to reshape the nose. This type of rhinoplasty is performed exclusively from within the nose itself, with no external cuts or incisions. The surgeon accesses and works on all areas of the nose through the nostrils. This allows for greater precision and control when sculpting the underlying structures of the nose.

The surgery typically involves repositioning, reshaping and/or removing cartilage and bone from the nasal framework to create a more aesthetically pleasing result. It can also involve adjusting tissue and rearranging soft tissue in order to create an improved shape and size for the nose. Because this procedure is done without any external incisions, it is usually associated with less swelling, bruising, and scarring than open rhinoplasty.

Closed rhinoplasty requires significant skill on the part of the surgeon in order to successfully perform this delicate procedure without leaving any visible signs of surgery. For these reasons, it is important that you seek out a qualified plastic surgeon who has extensive experience performing this type of surgery in order to ensure optimal results.

Advantages Of Open Rhinoplasty

Open rhinoplasty has many advantages over closed rhinoplasty. It allows for a more comprehensive approach to nasal reshaping, allowing the surgeon to have better access and visibility of the underlying structures of the nose. With open rhinoplasty, there is less risk of over resection and more accuracy in achieving desired results. The incisions used in open rhinoplasty are made inside the nostrils, so scarring is minimal and hidden from view.

The open approach also offers greater flexibility in addressing complex problems such as correcting deviated septum or addressing structural defects like drooping or oversized noses. For these cases, the surgeon can make precise alterations that would not be possible with a closed approach. Open rhinoplasty also offers improved precision when performing tip work, allowing for a more natural shape with less risk of complications.

Open rhinoplasty can provide quicker recovery times than closed approaches because it reduces tissue manipulation and avoids unnecessary trauma to the nose structures. This makes it an ideal option for those who want minimal downtime as well as long-term results. With an experienced surgeon, patients can expect excellent aesthetic outcomes with minimal scarring and softer, natural looking results.

Disadvantages Of Open Rhinoplasty

Open rhinoplasty can be beneficial for complex nasal surgeries, but there are some drawbacks compared to a closed rhinoplasty. One disadvantage of open rhinoplasty is the visible scar. The incision made across the columella leaves a permanent scar that is visible even after healing. Some patients may also experience numbness in the area around the scar and along the tip of the nose due to nerve damage that can occur during surgery.

Another disadvantage of open rhinoplasty is that it takes longer to complete than a closed rhinoplasty. This means more time under general anesthesia, which carries its own risks. Additionally, because of the increased visibility during an open procedure, there is a higher risk of making mistakes or misjudgments than with a closed approach.

Finally, open rhinoplasty can result in more swelling and bruising than a closed procedure due to the added trauma to soft tissue and skin around the nose. Healing time can take longer as well, meaning patients must wait longer before they see their final results.

Advantages Of Closed Rhinoplasty

Having discussed the disadvantages of open rhinoplasty, let’s now focus on the advantages of closed rhinoplasty. Closed rhinoplasty is a surgical technique that allows for subtle and precise modifications to be made to the nose without any visible incisions or scars being left behind. This type of procedure involves making all the necessary adjustments from inside the nose, with no cutting or repositioning of the nasal tissues required.

Closed rhinoplasty offers several unique benefits compared to open rhinoplasty. For one, this type of procedure can be completed much more quickly than an open technique. Since there’s less tissue manipulation involved, it takes much less time to complete the surgery. Additionally, because there are no external incisions made during closed rhinoplasty, patients experience minimal scarring and faster healing times. Finally, this type of procedure can also provide better aesthetic results as it allows for more precise control over how each part of the nose is reshaped and modified.

The closed rhinoplasty technique has become increasingly popular in recent years due to its numerous benefits. It offers patients a safe, quick and effective way to improve their facial features without having visible scars or a lengthy recovery period. The precise control over how each part of the nose is reshaped makes it an ideal option for individuals looking to make subtle yet significant changes to their appearance without sacrificing natural beauty.

Disadvantages Of Closed Rhinoplasty

Closed rhinoplasty is a less invasive approach than open rhinoplasty and is performed through incisions inside the nostrils. While this method usually involves fewer steps and a quicker recovery, there are some disadvantages to consider. First, the view of the nasal structure is more limited with closed rhinoplasty. This can make it difficult for surgeons to accurately assess the size and shape of internal structures or diagnose certain medical conditions such as a deviated septum. Second, because closed rhinoplasty requires smaller incisions, there may be less flexibility when it comes to correcting the shape of the nose. Lastly, access to cartilage grafts is also limited due to these smaller incisions. As a result, complex structural changes cannot be achieved as easily with closed rhinoplasty as they can with open rhinoplasty. For these reasons, it’s important for patients to discuss their goals with their surgeon prior to surgery so that they can decide which type of procedure is best suited for them.

Who Is A Good Candidate For Open Or Closed Rhinoplasty?

Open or closed rhinoplasty can improve the appearance of a person’s nose. However, some individuals are better suited for one procedure over the other. Here, I’ll discuss who is a good candidate for open or closed rhinoplasty.

Open rhinoplasty can provide dramatic results and is typically used to make more significant changes to the nose. It is best for those who are looking for an increase in size, angle, or shape of the nose. Additionally, it allows for better visualization of all structures involved with the surgery so that corrections can be made as needed during surgery. Open rhinoplasty may also be suitable for those with thicker skin, larger noses, and previous nasal trauma or surgeries.

Closed rhinoplasty is ideal for simpler procedures such as reshaping cartilage, removing bumps from the bridge of the nose, and refining the tip of the nose. It involves making smaller incisions inside each nostril which often heals faster than an open approach and leaves less visible scarring. Also known as endonasal rhinoplasty, this technique generally works well with thinner skinned patients with minor deformities such as a small hump on their bridge and a slightly droopy tip.

Overall, both open and closed rhinoplasty can produce satisfactory outcomes depending on a patient’s individual needs and goals. Therefore it is important to discuss these options with your surgeon prior to making any decisions about your procedure. With careful evaluation and planning we can determine which approach will provide you with optimal results while addressing your concerns in a safe manner

The Procedure For Open Or Closed Rhinoplasty

Open rhinoplasty and closed rhinoplasty are two distinct procedures for reshaping the nose. Open rhinoplasty involves making an incision on the outside of the nose, while closed rhinoplasty is performed with all incisions hidden inside the nose. Both techniques provide excellent results but they have different advantages.

In open rhinoplasty, I make a small incision between the nostrils to gain access to the underlying structures of the nose. This allows me to easily sculpt, remove or rearrange tissue as needed to achieve the desired outcome. It also gives me a better view of all structures involved in reshaping the nose, allowing for a more accurate result. However, this approach leaves visible scars on either side of the base of your nose that take several weeks or months to fade away.

Closed rhinoplasty is performed by making small incisions within the nostrils and does not leave any visible scarring. It is often preferred by patients who don’t want any visible signs from their procedure. With closed technique I can still see most of what needs to be done but it offers a less precise view than open technique due to limited access from inside your nostrils. As such, it requires greater experience and skill on my part in order to achieve excellent results.

Rhinoplasty can be highly individualized depending on your unique facial features and desired outcome. After assessing your anatomy in detail, I will determine which procedure best suits you and explain why this option is preferable over other alternatives. Together we will discuss every aspect of your surgery so that you feel comfortable proceeding with treatment and confident about achieving your ideal look.

Recovery And Aftercare For Open Or Closed Rhinoplasty

Open rhinoplasty and closed rhinoplasty are two surgical techniques used for reshaping the nose. Both procedures require adequate recovery and aftercare to ensure optimal results.

The recovery period following an open rhinoplasty is generally longer than that of a closed procedure. Patients may experience swelling, bruising, and discomfort around the nose and eyes. During this time, they should keep their head elevated and apply cold compresses to reduce inflammation. It is also important to follow the surgeon’s postoperative instructions regarding rest, activity level, medications and wound care. In most cases, patients can expect to return to normal activities within two weeks up to a month after surgery.

In contrast, closed rhinoplasty typically involves less swelling and quicker recovery times. After surgery, patients should carefully follow all of their doctor’s instructions for healing properly. This includes avoiding strenuous activities for several weeks as well as keeping the head elevated when sleeping or resting in order to minimize swelling. Cold compresses can also be beneficial in reducing any discomfort associated with the procedure. Generally speaking, most people are able to resume regular activities within one week following a closed rhinoplasty procedure.

It is essential for patients undergoing either type of rhinoplasty surgery to take proper care of themselves during their recovery period in order to achieve desired results from their operation.

Cost Comparison Between Open And Closed Rhinoplasty

Now that you have a better understanding of the recovery and aftercare associated with open and closed rhinoplasty, it is important to consider the cost difference between these two procedures. Open rhinoplasty is typically more expensive than closed rhinoplasty due to its complexity. With open rhinoplasty, the surgeon will make an incision across the columella, which is the narrow strip of tissue separating the nostrils. This requires a more detailed approach and often requires additional steps such as cartilage grafting or bone trimming.

Closed rhinoplasty does not require any external incisions and instead relies on small incisions within the nostrils. This approach typically takes less time for a surgeon to perform, resulting in lower costs for patients who opt for this procedure. Additionally, since no external incisions are made, there is less risk of scarring.

Despite its higher cost, many patients choose open rhinoplasty because it allows for more precise adjustments to be made to their nose shape and size. Open rhinoplasty also provides surgeons with better visibility during surgery, allowing them to make more accurate modifications that can help achieve desired results faster than closed rhinoplasty.


Rhinoplasty is a very personal procedure, and it’s important to choose the option that best fits your individual needs. Open rhinoplasty and closed rhinoplasty both have their advantages and disadvantages. For those looking for more complex changes to the nose, open rhinoplasty may be the best choice. However, closed rhinoplasty can also produce excellent results while minimizing scarring and downtime. Ultimately, I recommend discussing with your surgeon what type of procedure would be best for you in order to get the desired outcome.

No matter which type of rhinoplasty you choose, it’s essential that you find an experienced surgeon who can provide excellent care throughout your journey. When selecting a plastic surgeon, make sure they are board-certified and experienced in performing both open and closed rhinoplasties. With their expertise, you can feel confident that you will receive the highest quality of care with optimal results.

Whether through open or closed rhinoplasty, I am confident that I can help you achieve your desired outcome. With my experience in performing both types of procedures, I will be able to assess your individual needs and create a customized treatment plan tailored specifically to you. Together we will create the beautiful nose shape you desire!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


We are here to help you. Learn more about who we are and what we do.


Ask Us A Question About Nose Surgery and cosmetic surgery
Make An Appointment - history of rhinoplasty
New Patient Forms - nasal obstruction

Contact Us

    Call to schedule an appointment